{"id":4188,"date":"2020-10-30T21:44:30","date_gmt":"2020-10-30T20:44:30","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/?p=4188"},"modified":"2020-10-30T21:44:30","modified_gmt":"2020-10-30T20:44:30","slug":"webhoster-liable-for-data-loss-after-server-crash","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/da\/webhoster-haftet-fuer-datenverlust-nach-server-crash\/","title":{"rendered":"Webhoster ansvarlig for tab af data efter et servernedbrud"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>Hvis et servernedbrud f\u00f8rer til, at en <a href=\"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/da\/eine-eigene-webseite-fuer-ihr-unternehmen-ja-oder-nein\/\">Websted<\/a>webhostingudbyderen skal betale erstatning, hvis han har undladt at oprette sikkerhedskopier eller foretage sikkerhedskopier. Skadeserstatningen afh\u00e6nger af webstedets \"alder\".<\/p>\n<p>I sin dom af 22. juli 2014 (sag nr. 22 O 102\/12) fastslog den regionale domstol i Duisburg <a href=\"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/da\/was-ist-ein-webhoster\/\">Webhost<\/a> ind i forpligtelsen. De skal ogs\u00e5 oprette sikkerhedskopier af de websteder, de administrerer, hvis dette ikke udtrykkeligt er aftalt.<\/p>\n<h2>Sagen<\/h2>\n<p>Klageren fik i 2006 oprettet et websted til en pris p\u00e5 over 5.000 euro. I midten af 2011 bestilte hun den nuv\u00e6rende sags\u00f8gte med webhosting og betalte 24 euro om m\u00e5neden for det. Sags\u00f8gte gav p\u00e5 sin side en underleverand\u00f8r i opdrag. I midten af 2012 gik underleverand\u00f8rens server ned, hvilket medf\u00f8rte, at sags\u00f8gerens websted ikke l\u00e6ngere fungerede. Sags\u00f8geren anmodede sags\u00f8gte om at genoprette stedet. Sags\u00f8gte oplyste, at der blev gjort fors\u00f8g p\u00e5 at genoprette hjemmesiden. <a href=\"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/da\/personenbezogene-daten-sozialen-netzwerken\/\">Data<\/a> Resultatet skulle afventes. Faktisk kunne webstedet ikke genaktiveres, fordi der ikke var blevet oprettet nogen sikkerhedskopi, og det var derfor ikke muligt at gendanne dataene.<\/p>\n<p>Sags\u00f8geren ans\u00e5 dette for at v\u00e6re en tilsides\u00e6ttelse af sin kontraktpartner og sags\u00f8gte denne for over 8.000 euro i erstatning, best\u00e5ende af ca. 5.500 euro for oprettelsen af et nyt websted og 500 euro i m\u00e5nedlig kompensation for tabt brug.<\/p>\n<p>Sags\u00f8gte anmodede om at f\u00e5 sagen afvist med den begrundelse, at v\u00e6rtskontrakten ikke indeholdt nogen forpligtelse til at oprette sikkerhedskopier eller til at foretage passende sikkerhedskopier. Desuden var nogle data fra det gamle websted stadig tilg\u00e6ngelige, hvilket kunne have reduceret den n\u00f8dvendige indsats for at oprette et nyt websted. Sags\u00f8geren unders\u00f8gte ikke dette og tilsidesatte derfor sin pligt til at begr\u00e6nse skaden.<\/p>\n<h2>Sikkerhedskopiering af data som en kontraktlig sekund\u00e6r forpligtelse<\/h2>\n<p>Landsretten i Duisburg gav sags\u00f8geren medhold. Der var indg\u00e5et en s\u00e5kaldt v\u00e6rtsleverand\u00f8rkontrakt mellem parterne. Dette havde aspekter vedr\u00f8rende service, udlejning og arbejdskontrakter. Beskyttelse af de anvendte data var af stor betydning for brugeren. Derfor var det en sekund\u00e6r forpligtelse for webhotellet at tr\u00e6ffe de n\u00f8dvendige foranstaltninger til databeskyttelse, hvilket kunne ske ved hj\u00e6lp af sikkerhedskopier eller backups.  I denne henseende har v\u00e6rten pligt til at vedligeholde og passe p\u00e5. Der var derfor ikke behov for en udtrykkelig aftale om sikkerhedskopiering af data. Og det sags\u00f8gte selskab skal ogs\u00e5 p\u00e5tage sig ansvaret for den fejl, der er beg\u00e5et af dets underleverand\u00f8r, hvor servernedbruddet var sket.<\/p>\n<p>Desuden havde sags\u00f8geren kvantificeret sin skade i konkrete termer. Der foreligger ikke en tilsides\u00e6ttelse af pligten til at begr\u00e6nse skaden, da sags\u00f8gte af egen drift burde have oplyst, at den stadig havde data.<\/p>\n<p>Det f\u00f8lger af alt det foreg\u00e5ende, at sags\u00f8geren har ret til erstatning.<\/p>\n<h2>Fradrag \"nyt for gammelt\" ogs\u00e5 for websteder<\/h2>\n<p>Bel\u00f8bet for erstatningskravet blev imidlertid af landsretten ansl\u00e5et betydeligt lavere end sags\u00f8geren, som kun fik tildelt 1.264,51 euro.<\/p>\n<p>Der blev foretaget et s\u00e5kaldt \"nyt for gammelt\"-fradrag, som det ogs\u00e5 er tilf\u00e6ldet med motork\u00f8ret\u00f8jer, der er beskadiget ved ulykker. Ved vurderingen af erstatningsbel\u00f8bet st\u00f8ttede retten sig p\u00e5 en ekspert, der udtalte, at den gennemsnitlige levetid for et websted er 8 \u00e5r. Dette blev ikke modsagt af klagerens argument om, at hun havde \u00f8nsket at bruge det \"gamle\" websted i en ubegr\u00e6nset periode. Det var indlysende, at sags\u00f8geren ville have bestilt et nyt websted p\u00e5 et senere tidspunkt, selv om det tidligere websted ikke var blevet \u00f8delagt.<\/p>\n<p>Landsretten n\u00e6gtede sags\u00f8geren erstatning for brugsfortabelse helt og holdent, fordi hun ikke havde fremlagt og bevist nogen kendsgerninger, der udgjorde \"tilstr\u00e6kkeligt h\u00e5ndgribeligt bevis\" til at vurdere brugsfortabelse.<\/p>\n<p>Dommen er ikke retligt bindende. If\u00f8lge sags\u00f8geren har hun anket sagen, s\u00e5 den n\u00e6ste sag skal behandles af den h\u00f8jere landsret i D\u00fcsseldorf.<\/p>","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>F\u00fchrt ein Server-Crash zum Ausfall einer Webseite, muss der Webhosting Anbieter Schadensersatz leisten, wenn er es vers\u00e4umt hat, Sicherungskopien zu erstellen oder Backups durchzuf\u00fchren. Die H\u00f6he des Schadensersatzes h\u00e4ngt vom &#8222;Alter&#8220; der Webseite ab. Das Landgericht Duisburg nimmt in seinem Urteil vom 22.07.2014 (Az. 22 O 102\/12) Webhoster in die Pflicht. Sie m\u00fcssen auch dann [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":653,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_acf_changed":false,"_crdt_document":"","inline_featured_image":false,"footnotes":""},"categories":[674],"tags":[191,192],"class_list":["post-4188","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","hentry","category-web_hosting","tag-datenverlust","tag-schadenersatz"],"acf":[],"_wp_attached_file":null,"_wp_attachment_metadata":null,"litespeed-optimize-size":null,"litespeed-optimize-set":null,"_elementor_source_image_hash":null,"_wp_attachment_image_alt":null,"stockpack_author_name":null,"stockpack_author_url":null,"stockpack_provider":null,"stockpack_image_url":null,"stockpack_license":null,"stockpack_license_url":null,"stockpack_modification":null,"color":null,"original_id":null,"original_url":null,"original_link":null,"unsplash_location":null,"unsplash_sponsor":null,"unsplash_exif":null,"unsplash_attachment_metadata":null,"_elementor_is_screenshot":null,"surfer_file_name":null,"surfer_file_original_url":null,"envato_tk_source_kit":null,"envato_tk_source_index":null,"envato_tk_manifest":null,"envato_tk_folder_name":null,"envato_tk_builder":null,"envato_elements_download_event":null,"_menu_item_type":null,"_menu_item_menu_item_parent":null,"_menu_item_object_id":null,"_menu_item_object":null,"_menu_item_target":null,"_menu_item_classes":null,"_menu_item_xfn":null,"_menu_item_url":null,"_trp_menu_languages":null,"rank_math_primary_category":null,"rank_math_title":null,"inline_featured_image":null,"_yoast_wpseo_primary_category":null,"rank_math_schema_blogposting":null,"rank_math_schema_videoobject":null,"_oembed_049c719bc4a9f89deaead66a7da9fddc":null,"_oembed_time_049c719bc4a9f89deaead66a7da9fddc":null,"_yoast_wpseo_focuskw":"","_yoast_wpseo_linkdex":null,"_oembed_27e3473bf8bec795fbeb3a9d38489348":null,"_oembed_c3b0f6959478faf92a1f343d8f96b19e":null,"_trp_translated_slug_en_us":null,"_wp_desired_post_slug":null,"_yoast_wpseo_title":null,"tldname":null,"tldpreis":null,"tldrubrik":null,"tldpolicylink":null,"tldsize":null,"tldregistrierungsdauer":null,"tldtransfer":null,"tldwhoisprivacy":null,"tldregistrarchange":null,"tldregistrantchange":null,"tldwhoisupdate":null,"tldnameserverupdate":null,"tlddeletesofort":null,"tlddeleteexpire":null,"tldumlaute":null,"tldrestore":null,"tldsubcategory":null,"tldbildname":null,"tldbildurl":null,"tldclean":null,"tldcategory":null,"tldpolicy":null,"tldbesonderheiten":null,"tld_bedeutung":null,"_oembed_d167040d816d8f94c072940c8009f5f8":null,"_oembed_b0a0fa59ef14f8870da2c63f2027d064":null,"_oembed_4792fa4dfb2a8f09ab950a73b7f313ba":null,"_oembed_33ceb1fe54a8ab775d9410abf699878d":null,"_oembed_fd7014d14d919b45ec004937c0db9335":null,"_oembed_21a029d076783ec3e8042698c351bd7e":null,"_oembed_be5ea8a0c7b18e658f08cc571a909452":null,"_oembed_a9ca7a298b19f9b48ec5914e010294d2":null,"_oembed_f8db6b27d08a2bb1f920e7647808899a":null,"_oembed_168ebde5096e77d8a89326519af9e022":null,"_oembed_cdb76f1b345b42743edfe25481b6f98f":null,"_oembed_87b0613611ae54e86e8864265404b0a1":null,"_oembed_27aa0e5cf3f1bb4bc416a4641a5ac273":null,"_oembed_time_27aa0e5cf3f1bb4bc416a4641a5ac273":null,"_tldname":null,"_tldclean":null,"_tldpreis":null,"_tldcategory":null,"_tldsubcategory":null,"_tldpolicy":null,"_tldpolicylink":null,"_tldsize":null,"_tldregistrierungsdauer":null,"_tldtransfer":null,"_tldwhoisprivacy":null,"_tldregistrarchange":null,"_tldregistrantchange":null,"_tldwhoisupdate":null,"_tldnameserverupdate":null,"_tlddeletesofort":null,"_tlddeleteexpire":null,"_tldumlaute":null,"_tldrestore":null,"_tldbildname":null,"_tldbildurl":null,"_tld_bedeutung":null,"_tldbesonderheiten":null,"_oembed_ad96e4112edb9f8ffa35731d4098bc6b":null,"_oembed_8357e2b8a2575c74ed5978f262a10126":null,"_oembed_3d5fea5103dd0d22ec5d6a33eff7f863":null,"_eael_widget_elements":null,"_oembed_0d8a206f09633e3d62b95a15a4dd0487":null,"_oembed_time_0d8a206f09633e3d62b95a15a4dd0487":null,"_aioseo_description":null,"_eb_attr":null,"_eb_data_table":null,"_oembed_819a879e7da16dd629cfd15a97334c8a":null,"_oembed_time_819a879e7da16dd629cfd15a97334c8a":null,"_acf_changed":null,"_wpcode_auto_insert":null,"_edit_last":null,"_edit_lock":null,"_oembed_e7b913c6c84084ed9702cb4feb012ddd":null,"_oembed_bfde9e10f59a17b85fc8917fa7edf782":null,"_oembed_time_bfde9e10f59a17b85fc8917fa7edf782":null,"_oembed_03514b67990db061d7c4672de26dc514":null,"_oembed_time_03514b67990db061d7c4672de26dc514":null,"rank_math_news_sitemap_robots":"index","rank_math_robots":["index"],"_eael_post_view_count":"4842","_trp_automatically_translated_slug_ru_ru":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_et":"webhoster-kohustuslik-andmekaotuse-paerast-server-krahhi","_trp_automatically_translated_slug_lv":"webhoster-liable-for-data-loss-after-server-crash","_trp_automatically_translated_slug_fr_fr":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_en_us":null,"_wp_old_slug":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_da_dk":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_pl_pl":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_es_es":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_hu_hu":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_fi":"webhoster-vastuu-tietohaevioestae-palvelimen-kaatumisen-jaelkeen","_trp_automatically_translated_slug_ja":"%e3%82%b5%e3%83%bc%e3%83%90%e3%83%bc%e3%82%af%e3%83%a9%e3%83%83%e3%82%b7%e3%83%a5%e5%be%8c%e3%81%ae%e3%83%87%e3%83%bc%e3%82%bf%e6%90%8d%e5%a4%b1%e3%81%ab%e5%af%be%e3%81%99%e3%82%8b%e3%82%a6%e3%82%a7","_trp_automatically_translated_slug_lt_lt":null,"_elementor_edit_mode":null,"_elementor_template_type":null,"_elementor_version":null,"_elementor_pro_version":null,"_wp_page_template":"default","_elementor_page_settings":null,"_elementor_data":null,"_elementor_css":null,"_elementor_conditions":null,"_happyaddons_elements_cache":null,"_oembed_75446120c39305f0da0ccd147f6de9cb":null,"_oembed_time_75446120c39305f0da0ccd147f6de9cb":null,"_oembed_3efb2c3e76a18143e7207993a2a6939a":null,"_oembed_time_3efb2c3e76a18143e7207993a2a6939a":null,"_oembed_59808117857ddf57e478a31d79f76e4d":null,"_oembed_time_59808117857ddf57e478a31d79f76e4d":null,"_oembed_965c5b49aa8d22ce37dfb3bde0268600":null,"_oembed_time_965c5b49aa8d22ce37dfb3bde0268600":null,"_oembed_81002f7ee3604f645db4ebcfd1912acf":null,"_oembed_time_81002f7ee3604f645db4ebcfd1912acf":null,"_elementor_screenshot":null,"_oembed_7ea3429961cf98fa85da9747683af827":null,"_oembed_time_7ea3429961cf98fa85da9747683af827":null,"_elementor_controls_usage":null,"_elementor_page_assets":[],"_elementor_screenshot_failed":null,"theplus_transient_widgets":["tp-video-player"],"_eael_custom_js":null,"_wp_old_date":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_it_it":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_pt_pt":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_zh_cn":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_nl_nl":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_pt_br":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_sv_se":null,"rank_math_analytic_object_id":"871","rank_math_internal_links_processed":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_ro_ro":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_sk_sk":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_bg_bg":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_sl_si":null,"litespeed_vpi_list":["webhostinglogo.png"],"litespeed_vpi_list_mobile":["webhostinglogo.png"],"rank_math_seo_score":null,"rank_math_contentai_score":null,"ilj_limitincominglinks":null,"ilj_maxincominglinks":null,"ilj_limitoutgoinglinks":null,"ilj_maxoutgoinglinks":null,"ilj_limitlinksperparagraph":null,"ilj_linksperparagraph":null,"ilj_blacklistdefinition":null,"ilj_linkdefinition":["webhoster haftet f\u00fcr datenverlust nach server-crash"],"_eb_reusable_block_ids":null,"rank_math_focus_keyword":null,"rank_math_og_content_image":null,"_yoast_wpseo_metadesc":"","_yoast_wpseo_content_score":null,"_yoast_wpseo_focuskeywords":null,"_yoast_wpseo_keywordsynonyms":null,"_yoast_wpseo_estimated-reading-time-minutes":null,"rank_math_description":null,"surfer_last_post_update":null,"surfer_last_post_update_direction":null,"surfer_keywords":null,"surfer_location":null,"surfer_draft_id":null,"surfer_permalink_hash":null,"surfer_scrape_ready":null,"_thumbnail_id":"653","footnotes":null,"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/da\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/4188","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/da\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/da\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/da\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/da\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=4188"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/da\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/4188\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/da\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/653"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/da\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=4188"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/da\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=4188"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/da\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=4188"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}