{"id":4188,"date":"2020-10-30T21:44:30","date_gmt":"2020-10-30T20:44:30","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/?p=4188"},"modified":"2020-10-30T21:44:30","modified_gmt":"2020-10-30T20:44:30","slug":"webhoster-liable-for-data-loss-after-server-crash","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/pl\/webhoster-haftet-fuer-datenverlust-nach-server-crash\/","title":{"rendered":"Webhoster odpowiedzialny za utrat\u0119 danych po awarii serwera"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>Je\u015bli awaria serwera doprowadzi do awarii <a href=\"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/pl\/eine-eigene-webseite-fuer-ihr-unternehmen-ja-oder-nein\/\">strona internetowa<\/a>dostawca us\u0142ug hostingowych musi zap\u0142aci\u0107 odszkodowanie, je\u015bli nie uda\u0142o mu si\u0119 stworzy\u0107 kopii zapasowych lub wykona\u0107 kopie zapasowe. Wysoko\u015b\u0107 odszkodowania zale\u017cy od \"wieku\" strony.<\/p>\n<p>W wyroku z dnia 22.07.2014 r. (sprawa nr 22 O 102\/12) S\u0105d Okr\u0119gowy w Duisburgu stwierdzi\u0142, \u017ce <a href=\"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/pl\/was-ist-ein-webhoster\/\">Web Host<\/a> ...w s\u0142u\u017cbie. Musz\u0105 oni tworzy\u0107 kopie zapasowe zarz\u0105dzanych przez siebie stron internetowych, nawet je\u015bli nie zosta\u0142o to wyra\u017anie uzgodnione.<\/p>\n<h2>Sprawa<\/h2>\n<p>W 2006 roku pow\u00f3d mia\u0142 stron\u0119 internetow\u0105 stworzon\u0105 za ponad 5.000 euro. W po\u0142owie 2011 r. zleci\u0142a obecnemu pozwanemu hosting stron internetowych i zap\u0142aci\u0142a za to 24 euro miesi\u0119cznie. Strona pozwana z kolei zleci\u0142a podwykonawcy. W po\u0142owie 2012 roku podwykonawca dozna\u0142 awarii serwera, w wyniku kt\u00f3rej strona internetowa powoda przesta\u0142a funkcjonowa\u0107. Pow\u00f3d poprosi\u0142 pozwanego o odtworzenie terenu. Oskar\u017cony o\u015bwiadczy\u0142, \u017ce usi\u0142owa\u0142 <a href=\"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/pl\/personenbezogene-daten-sozialen-netzwerken\/\">Dane<\/a> aby zaoszcz\u0119dzi\u0107, rezultatem by\u0142o czekanie. W rzeczywisto\u015bci reaktywacja strony nie powiod\u0142a si\u0119, poniewa\u017c nie zosta\u0142a utworzona \u017cadna kopia zapasowa, a zatem przywr\u00f3cenie danych nie by\u0142o mo\u017cliwe.<\/p>\n<p>Pow\u00f3d uzna\u0142 to za naruszenie obowi\u0105zku staranno\u015bci przez swojego partnera umownego i pozwa\u0142 go o odszkodowanie w wysoko\u015bci ponad 8.000 euro, na kt\u00f3re sk\u0142ada si\u0119 oko\u0142o 5.500 euro za stworzenie nowej strony internetowej oraz 500 euro miesi\u0119cznego odszkodowania za utrat\u0119 mo\u017cliwo\u015bci korzystania z niej.<\/p>\n<p>Strona pozwana wnios\u0142a o oddalenie skargi, argumentuj\u0105c, \u017ce umowa o hosting nie zawiera\u0142a \u017cadnego zobowi\u0105zania do tworzenia kopii zapasowych ani do tworzenia odpowiednich kopii zapasowych. Ponadto, niekt\u00f3re dane ze starej strony internetowej by\u0142y nadal dost\u0119pne, co mog\u0142o zmniejszy\u0107 wysi\u0142ek potrzebny do stworzenia nowej strony. Pow\u00f3d nie zapyta\u0142 o to i w zwi\u0105zku z tym naruszy\u0142 sw\u00f3j obowi\u0105zek z\u0142agodzenia szkody.<\/p>\n<h2>Kopia zapasowa danych jako dodatkowe zobowi\u0105zanie umowne<\/h2>\n<p>S\u0105d Okr\u0119gowy w Duisburgu orzek\u0142 na korzy\u015b\u0107 powoda. Strony zawar\u0142y tak zwan\u0105 umow\u0119 z gospodarzem-dostawc\u0105. Mia\u0142a ona aspekty us\u0142ugowe, wynajmu i umowy o prac\u0119. Ochrona wykorzystywanych danych mia\u0142a istotne znaczenie dla u\u017cytkownika. W zwi\u0105zku z tym na gospodarzu sieciowym spoczywa\u0142 wt\u00f3rny obowi\u0105zek podj\u0119cia niezb\u0119dnych \u015brodk\u00f3w ochrony danych, co mo\u017cna by\u0142o osi\u0105gn\u0105\u0107 poprzez tworzenie kopii zapasowych lub kopii zapasowych.  W zwi\u0105zku z tym na organizatorze ci\u0105\u017cy obowi\u0105zek utrzymania i opieki. Nie by\u0142o zatem potrzeby wyra\u017anej zgody na tworzenie kopii zapasowych danych. Pozwana firma musi r\u00f3wnie\u017c przyj\u0105\u0107 na siebie odpowiedzialno\u015b\u0107 za win\u0119 swojego podwykonawcy, u kt\u00f3rego dosz\u0142o do awarii serwera.<\/p>\n<p>Ponadto strona skar\u017c\u0105ca okre\u015bli\u0142a konkretn\u0105 wysoko\u015b\u0107 szkody. Nie dosz\u0142o do naruszenia obowi\u0105zku minimalizacji szkody, poniewa\u017c pozwana powinna by\u0142a o\u015bwiadczy\u0107 z w\u0142asnej woli, \u017ce nadal posiada pliki danych.<\/p>\n<p>Z ca\u0142o\u015bci powy\u017cszych rozwa\u017ca\u0144 wynika, \u017ce skar\u017c\u0105ca ma prawo do odszkodowania.<\/p>\n<h2>odliczenie \"nowe za stare\" r\u00f3wnie\u017c dla stron internetowych<\/h2>\n<p>S\u0105d Okr\u0119gowy stwierdzi\u0142 jednak, \u017ce kwota roszczenia odszkodowawczego jest znacznie ni\u017csza od kwoty zas\u0105dzonej przez powoda, kt\u00f3ry otrzyma\u0142 zaledwie 1 264,51 EUR.<\/p>\n<p>Dokonano tzw. odliczenia \"nowe za stare\", kt\u00f3re stosuje si\u0119 r\u00f3wnie\u017c do pojazd\u00f3w uszkodzonych w wypadkach. Oceniaj\u0105c wysoko\u015b\u0107 odszkodowania, s\u0105d opar\u0142 si\u0119 na o\u015bwiadczeniach bieg\u0142ego, kt\u00f3ry stwierdzi\u0142, \u017ce \u015bredni okres u\u017cytkowania strony internetowej wynosi\u0142 8 lat. Nie zaprzeczy\u0142 temu argument pow\u00f3dki, \u017ce chcia\u0142a korzysta\u0107 ze \"starej\" strony internetowej przez nieograniczony czas. Jest oczywiste, \u017ce pow\u00f3d zleci\u0142by w przysz\u0142o\u015bci stworzenie nowej strony internetowej, nawet je\u015bli poprzednia nie zosta\u0142aby zniszczona.<\/p>\n<p>S\u0105d Okr\u0119gowy ca\u0142kowicie odm\u00f3wi\u0142 pow\u00f3dce odszkodowania za utrat\u0119 u\u017cytkowania, poniewa\u017c nie przedstawi\u0142a ona i nie udowodni\u0142a \u017cadnych fakt\u00f3w, kt\u00f3re dostarczy\u0142yby \"wystarczaj\u0105cych namacalnych dowod\u00f3w\" do oceny utraty u\u017cytkowania.<\/p>\n<p>Wyrok nie jest ostateczny. Zgodnie z jej w\u0142asnym o\u015bwiadczeniem, pow\u00f3dka z\u0142o\u017cy\u0142a apelacj\u0119, w zwi\u0105zku z czym nast\u0119pnie sprawa b\u0119dzie musia\u0142a zosta\u0107 rozpatrzona przez Wy\u017cszy S\u0105d Okr\u0119gowy w D\u00fcsseldorfie.<\/p>","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>F\u00fchrt ein Server-Crash zum Ausfall einer Webseite, muss der Webhosting Anbieter Schadensersatz leisten, wenn er es vers\u00e4umt hat, Sicherungskopien zu erstellen oder Backups durchzuf\u00fchren. Die H\u00f6he des Schadensersatzes h\u00e4ngt vom &#8222;Alter&#8220; der Webseite ab. Das Landgericht Duisburg nimmt in seinem Urteil vom 22.07.2014 (Az. 22 O 102\/12) Webhoster in die Pflicht. Sie m\u00fcssen auch dann [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":653,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_acf_changed":false,"inline_featured_image":false,"footnotes":""},"categories":[674],"tags":[191,192],"class_list":["post-4188","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","hentry","category-web_hosting","tag-datenverlust","tag-schadenersatz"],"acf":[],"_wp_attached_file":null,"_wp_attachment_metadata":null,"litespeed-optimize-size":null,"litespeed-optimize-set":null,"_elementor_source_image_hash":null,"_wp_attachment_image_alt":null,"stockpack_author_name":null,"stockpack_author_url":null,"stockpack_provider":null,"stockpack_image_url":null,"stockpack_license":null,"stockpack_license_url":null,"stockpack_modification":null,"color":null,"original_id":null,"original_url":null,"original_link":null,"unsplash_location":null,"unsplash_sponsor":null,"unsplash_exif":null,"unsplash_attachment_metadata":null,"_elementor_is_screenshot":null,"surfer_file_name":null,"surfer_file_original_url":null,"envato_tk_source_kit":null,"envato_tk_source_index":null,"envato_tk_manifest":null,"envato_tk_folder_name":null,"envato_tk_builder":null,"envato_elements_download_event":null,"_menu_item_type":null,"_menu_item_menu_item_parent":null,"_menu_item_object_id":null,"_menu_item_object":null,"_menu_item_target":null,"_menu_item_classes":null,"_menu_item_xfn":null,"_menu_item_url":null,"_trp_menu_languages":null,"rank_math_primary_category":null,"rank_math_title":null,"inline_featured_image":null,"_yoast_wpseo_primary_category":null,"rank_math_schema_blogposting":null,"rank_math_schema_videoobject":null,"_oembed_049c719bc4a9f89deaead66a7da9fddc":null,"_oembed_time_049c719bc4a9f89deaead66a7da9fddc":null,"_yoast_wpseo_focuskw":"","_yoast_wpseo_linkdex":null,"_oembed_27e3473bf8bec795fbeb3a9d38489348":null,"_oembed_c3b0f6959478faf92a1f343d8f96b19e":null,"_trp_translated_slug_en_us":null,"_wp_desired_post_slug":null,"_yoast_wpseo_title":null,"tldname":null,"tldpreis":null,"tldrubrik":null,"tldpolicylink":null,"tldsize":null,"tldregistrierungsdauer":null,"tldtransfer":null,"tldwhoisprivacy":null,"tldregistrarchange":null,"tldregistrantchange":null,"tldwhoisupdate":null,"tldnameserverupdate":null,"tlddeletesofort":null,"tlddeleteexpire":null,"tldumlaute":null,"tldrestore":null,"tldsubcategory":null,"tldbildname":null,"tldbildurl":null,"tldclean":null,"tldcategory":null,"tldpolicy":null,"tldbesonderheiten":null,"tld_bedeutung":null,"_oembed_d167040d816d8f94c072940c8009f5f8":null,"_oembed_b0a0fa59ef14f8870da2c63f2027d064":null,"_oembed_4792fa4dfb2a8f09ab950a73b7f313ba":null,"_oembed_33ceb1fe54a8ab775d9410abf699878d":null,"_oembed_fd7014d14d919b45ec004937c0db9335":null,"_oembed_21a029d076783ec3e8042698c351bd7e":null,"_oembed_be5ea8a0c7b18e658f08cc571a909452":null,"_oembed_a9ca7a298b19f9b48ec5914e010294d2":null,"_oembed_f8db6b27d08a2bb1f920e7647808899a":null,"_oembed_168ebde5096e77d8a89326519af9e022":null,"_oembed_cdb76f1b345b42743edfe25481b6f98f":null,"_oembed_87b0613611ae54e86e8864265404b0a1":null,"_oembed_27aa0e5cf3f1bb4bc416a4641a5ac273":null,"_oembed_time_27aa0e5cf3f1bb4bc416a4641a5ac273":null,"_tldname":null,"_tldclean":null,"_tldpreis":null,"_tldcategory":null,"_tldsubcategory":null,"_tldpolicy":null,"_tldpolicylink":null,"_tldsize":null,"_tldregistrierungsdauer":null,"_tldtransfer":null,"_tldwhoisprivacy":null,"_tldregistrarchange":null,"_tldregistrantchange":null,"_tldwhoisupdate":null,"_tldnameserverupdate":null,"_tlddeletesofort":null,"_tlddeleteexpire":null,"_tldumlaute":null,"_tldrestore":null,"_tldbildname":null,"_tldbildurl":null,"_tld_bedeutung":null,"_tldbesonderheiten":null,"_oembed_ad96e4112edb9f8ffa35731d4098bc6b":null,"_oembed_8357e2b8a2575c74ed5978f262a10126":null,"_oembed_3d5fea5103dd0d22ec5d6a33eff7f863":null,"_eael_widget_elements":null,"_oembed_0d8a206f09633e3d62b95a15a4dd0487":null,"_oembed_time_0d8a206f09633e3d62b95a15a4dd0487":null,"_aioseo_description":null,"_eb_attr":null,"_eb_data_table":null,"_oembed_819a879e7da16dd629cfd15a97334c8a":null,"_oembed_time_819a879e7da16dd629cfd15a97334c8a":null,"_acf_changed":null,"_wpcode_auto_insert":null,"_edit_last":null,"_edit_lock":null,"_oembed_e7b913c6c84084ed9702cb4feb012ddd":null,"_oembed_bfde9e10f59a17b85fc8917fa7edf782":null,"_oembed_time_bfde9e10f59a17b85fc8917fa7edf782":null,"_oembed_03514b67990db061d7c4672de26dc514":null,"_oembed_time_03514b67990db061d7c4672de26dc514":null,"rank_math_news_sitemap_robots":"index","rank_math_robots":["index"],"_eael_post_view_count":"4898","_trp_automatically_translated_slug_ru_ru":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_et":"webhoster-kohustuslik-andmekaotuse-paerast-server-krahhi","_trp_automatically_translated_slug_lv":"webhoster-liable-for-data-loss-after-server-crash","_trp_automatically_translated_slug_fr_fr":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_en_us":null,"_wp_old_slug":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_da_dk":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_pl_pl":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_es_es":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_hu_hu":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_fi":"webhoster-vastuu-tietohaevioestae-palvelimen-kaatumisen-jaelkeen","_trp_automatically_translated_slug_ja":"%e3%82%b5%e3%83%bc%e3%83%90%e3%83%bc%e3%82%af%e3%83%a9%e3%83%83%e3%82%b7%e3%83%a5%e5%be%8c%e3%81%ae%e3%83%87%e3%83%bc%e3%82%bf%e6%90%8d%e5%a4%b1%e3%81%ab%e5%af%be%e3%81%99%e3%82%8b%e3%82%a6%e3%82%a7","_trp_automatically_translated_slug_lt_lt":null,"_elementor_edit_mode":null,"_elementor_template_type":null,"_elementor_version":null,"_elementor_pro_version":null,"_wp_page_template":"default","_elementor_page_settings":null,"_elementor_data":null,"_elementor_css":null,"_elementor_conditions":null,"_happyaddons_elements_cache":null,"_oembed_75446120c39305f0da0ccd147f6de9cb":null,"_oembed_time_75446120c39305f0da0ccd147f6de9cb":null,"_oembed_3efb2c3e76a18143e7207993a2a6939a":null,"_oembed_time_3efb2c3e76a18143e7207993a2a6939a":null,"_oembed_59808117857ddf57e478a31d79f76e4d":null,"_oembed_time_59808117857ddf57e478a31d79f76e4d":null,"_oembed_965c5b49aa8d22ce37dfb3bde0268600":null,"_oembed_time_965c5b49aa8d22ce37dfb3bde0268600":null,"_oembed_81002f7ee3604f645db4ebcfd1912acf":null,"_oembed_time_81002f7ee3604f645db4ebcfd1912acf":null,"_elementor_screenshot":null,"_oembed_7ea3429961cf98fa85da9747683af827":null,"_oembed_time_7ea3429961cf98fa85da9747683af827":null,"_elementor_controls_usage":null,"_elementor_page_assets":[],"_elementor_screenshot_failed":null,"theplus_transient_widgets":["tp-video-player"],"_eael_custom_js":null,"_wp_old_date":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_it_it":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_pt_pt":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_zh_cn":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_nl_nl":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_pt_br":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_sv_se":null,"rank_math_analytic_object_id":"871","rank_math_internal_links_processed":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_ro_ro":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_sk_sk":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_bg_bg":null,"_trp_automatically_translated_slug_sl_si":null,"litespeed_vpi_list":["webhostinglogo.png"],"litespeed_vpi_list_mobile":["webhostinglogo.png"],"rank_math_seo_score":null,"rank_math_contentai_score":null,"ilj_limitincominglinks":null,"ilj_maxincominglinks":null,"ilj_limitoutgoinglinks":null,"ilj_maxoutgoinglinks":null,"ilj_limitlinksperparagraph":null,"ilj_linksperparagraph":null,"ilj_blacklistdefinition":null,"ilj_linkdefinition":["webhoster haftet f\u00fcr datenverlust nach server-crash"],"_eb_reusable_block_ids":null,"rank_math_focus_keyword":null,"rank_math_og_content_image":null,"_yoast_wpseo_metadesc":"","_yoast_wpseo_content_score":null,"_yoast_wpseo_focuskeywords":null,"_yoast_wpseo_keywordsynonyms":null,"_yoast_wpseo_estimated-reading-time-minutes":null,"rank_math_description":null,"surfer_last_post_update":null,"surfer_last_post_update_direction":null,"surfer_keywords":null,"surfer_location":null,"surfer_draft_id":null,"surfer_permalink_hash":null,"surfer_scrape_ready":null,"_thumbnail_id":"653","footnotes":null,"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/4188","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=4188"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/4188\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/653"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=4188"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=4188"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/webhosting.de\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=4188"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}