Skip to content 
Enabling HSTS reliably protects websites from redirected HTTP connections and man-in-the-middle attacks. This article explains the technical background, shows the clear benefits and risks and provides easy-to-implement steps for the secure implementation of HTTP Strict Transport Security.
Key points
- Security gain through automatic HTTPS redirection and protection against SSL stripping
- HSTS preload protects you the first time you visit the site
- Certificates must be valid at all times, otherwise browsers will block access
- Risk of misconfiguration: difficult to undo if preload has been activated
- Server settings targeted testing before the policy applies to all users
What is HSTS and why is it essential?
HTTP Strict Transport Security (HSTS) forces the browser to do this, all connections encrypted via HTTPS. HSTS does not simply prevent HTTP connections from being reloaded - it specifically blocks them. As soon as the browser has received the Strict-Transport-Security header, it refuses every unencrypted request for the specified time. This prevents attackers from carrying out downgrade attacks by manipulating the protocol. HSTS is particularly advantageous when protecting mobile users in insecure WLAN networks.
Unlike simple HTTPS redirects, forced HTTPS usage remains stored in the browser and protects every subsequent connection. This persistence makes HSTS a powerful tool, but if configured incorrectly, it can also Permanent problems cause. It is important to understand that HSTS forces browsers to always use HTTPS, even if the user or a potential attacker tries to redirect them to HTTP. Especially in large or multi-layered server environments, it is therefore worth implementing this measure with care.
With a pure redirect from HTTP to HTTPS, there is still a risk that an attacker will override the redirect to HTTPS at the right moment (SSL stripping). HSTS, on the other hand, does not allow a fallback to insecure data. Another user-friendly feature is that nobody has to enter or click anything in the front end to surf in encrypted form - the browser automatically does the right thing in the background.
How HSTS is technically defined
The server issues an HSTS header for a secure HTTPS connection. Three parameters are decisive here:
| Parameters | Description |
|---|---|
| max-age | Time in seconds how long the browser should enforce HTTPS. Usually 31536000 seconds = 1 year. |
| includeSubDomains | Set the policy to all subdomains - also mandatory HTTPS. |
| preload | Enables entry in the browser-internal HSTS preload list. Protects users on their first visit. |
A typical HSTS header looks like this:
Strict-Transport-Security: max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preloadThe preload-flag has a special meaning here: domains that qualify for it end up in a list maintained by the common browser manufacturers. Chrome, Firefox, Edge and Safari load this list with every browser version for security reasons. When a user enters the site for the very first time, the HSTS policy already applies, even though no HSTS header has ever been transferred from the server. However, the browser manufacturer's specifications must be followed very carefully before the domain is entered.
Risks and challenges in use
If you want to activate HSTS, you should be aware of the potential side effects. The security mechanism is permanent as long as the max-age is not deliberately shortened. An incorrectly set "includeSubDomains" parameter can mean that internal subdomains are suddenly no longer accessible if no SSL certificate is valid there. In addition, browsers immediately block pages if connections marked as secure generate certificate errors. This means that an inadvertent misconfiguration can quickly lead to the failure of important services.
Inclusion in the preload list in particular is a decision with a long-term effect. Once the domain is anchored there, this can only be reversed with effort and waiting time. I recommend: First of all without preload start, test everything, rule out errors and then optionally add them. If you still want to use preload directly, you need very reliable certificate management processes. If a certificate expires, this can lead to a comprehensive revocation by browsers - and thus to a loss of customers or trust issues.
It should also be borne in mind that some browsers or devices with outdated operating systems do not yet support HSTS. Although this is rarely the case today, outdated browsers sometimes lead to confusing user feedback when they display error messages or bypass notices due to unsupported HSTS mechanisms. Such scenarios need to be tested in advance, especially if your target group uses older hardware.
How to activate HSTS securely - step by step
I have had good experiences with implementing the activation in a structured way:
- SSL Certificate (inexpensive e.g. via these instructions). Make sure you always use a valid certificate. An expired certificate will quickly lead to a complete blockage.
- Configure the Strict-Transport-Security header in the web server (e.g. via Apache .htaccess or Nginx configuration). A short test period helps here to ensure that all services are running correctly.
- Keep max-age short at the beginning - e.g. 300 seconds - for testing. This allows errors to be corrected quickly without users getting stuck with an incorrect HSTS configuration in the long term.
- Do not activate IncludeSubDomains at first, unless all subdomains are protected. Check each subdomain certificate, otherwise there is a risk of error messages or blocking.
- After a positive test: gradually increase max-age to up to 1 year. In this way, you gain security without taking risks too hastily.
- Use tools such as SSL Labs to analyze whether everything is correctly integrated. Here you can see immediately if areas of the website are not encrypted or the certificate has been configured incorrectly.
- Optional: Preload if all possible risks are permanently excluded. A preload entry represents the highest level and offers comprehensive protection from the first page view.
Especially in the initial phase, it is helpful to keep an eye on the server log. If a conspicuous number of 4xx or 5xx errors occur, the HSTS enforcement could be the cause. Some browsers also report problems much earlier if the configuration is incorrect. It is therefore worth carrying out a comprehensive test with different browsers (Chrome, Firefox, Safari, Edge), different end devices (smartphones, tablets) and older operating systems if necessary.
Important advantages of using HSTS
The benefits of HSTS are particularly evident on websites with confidential data. The mechanism specifically fends off attack vectors without users having to actively do anything. If HSTS is activated correctly, a modern browser immediately recognizes whether a connection is securely encrypted - or whether it needs to be blocked. In this way, HSTS strengthens the trust of visitors and helps you as the operator to maintain the integrity of your website.
Further advantages:
- SEO advantagesGoogle prefers sites that consistently use HTTPS. HSTS additionally underlines this HTTPS conviction - because those who use HSTS definitely rely on encryption.
- Compliance with current data protection requirements, for example in accordance with GDPR or ISO 27001, because no more unencrypted data is sent. This makes it easier to prove that sensitive information is consistently transmitted in encrypted form.
- Protection against session hijacking through misdirected HTTP calls. Even if a user unintentionally enters a URL without "https://", the browser forces an encrypted request.
- Avoid unnecessary redirects - users can access the page directly via HTTPS. This can slightly optimize the loading time and has a positive effect on the user experience.
Technically, the effect can be measured: Permanently blocking HTTP connections reduces the appearance of potential security vulnerabilities in web scanner results. This benefits SEO, data protection reports and the customer's impression in equal measure. A reliable HTTPS strategy can be a decisive unique selling point, especially now that security concerns are constantly growing among users.
What applies to HSTS in shared hosting environments
In shared hosting structures (shared or managed hosting), individual access to server configurations is usually restricted. That's why I first check whether my provider allows customizations via .htaccess - or whether an interface is provided. In many places, adding a line to the .htaccess is sufficient to output the HSTS header. Alternatively, some providers offer a corresponding setting in their administration interface (e.g. Plesk or cPanel).
A reliable HTTPS redirect is already a good sign. Instructions like this help for HTTPS forwarding provide an insight into sensible basic settings. However, simply redirecting to HTTPS is not enough to effectively prevent SSL stripping. If you want to enjoy full security, you should therefore also activate the HSTS option in shared hosting.
In some shared hosting environments, however, it can be complex to securely cover subdomains. Especially with external services or tools (e.g. webmail, customer area, blog), it must be ensured that all certificates are valid. Misconduct on a subdomain can otherwise lead to the entire domain being flagged as insecure. This can have a direct impact on your reputation and accessibility.
Best practices for safe use
Certificates expire - that is unavoidable. That's why I automate the renewal process using Let's Encrypt or other services with cronjobs, API or ACME protocol. Missing renewals cause browsers to block websites. This is how a security feature suddenly becomes a risk of failure.
Before activating includeSubDomains, I specifically test all relevant subdomains. Internal tools, old services or development directories in particular are often unprotected. I therefore do without this parameter or carefully secure each section of my platform before I use it. It is also important that all redirects are set up properly and that no mixed content problems occur. Mixed content occurs when the website is loaded via HTTPS, but individual files such as images, scripts or stylesheets are still integrated via HTTP. This would undermine consistent encryption and HSTS would not be able to develop its full effect.
We recommend the combined use of additional security headers such as Content security policy or X-Frame-Options. While HSTS secures the transport protocol, Content Security Policy takes care of controlling which external resources may be loaded. Together, this further minimizes the attack surface because potential cross-site scripting attempts or code injections become more difficult. Thorough planning ensures complementary protective measures.
You should also bear in mind that some users use outdated browsers. Although this is rare in practice today, it is worth providing a brief note or FAQ if a visitor with a very old browser complains. In individual cases, you can consider offering a separate page that prompts users to update their browser - although this may of course conflict with a strict HSTS configuration. In fact, however, you are doing users a favor if you motivate them to use an up-to-date browser version, as this is also beneficial in other areas (security gaps, rendering).
Correct monitoring after the roll-out
After activating HSTS, I regularly check various things: Are certificates still valid? Is the header being delivered correctly? Do my logs record TLS errors or strong traffic fluctuations? Tools such as cURL, Qualys SSL Labs or browser plugins help with the check. With careful observation, you can quickly find bottlenecks or recognize whether certain crawlers or bots are having problems.
If errors occur, I can make temporary resets locally via "About:config" in Firefox or corresponding dev tools. However, if preload is used, this is not a quick way out - the entry remains until the next browser update. Updates to the preload entry should therefore be secured very carefully, for example by meticulously checking the status of all subdomains and carrying out extensive tests before entering the domain.
Another factor is timing: especially when certificates are about to expire, a slight delay in automatic renewal can lead to browser warnings. Because the HSTS configuration window in the browser barely leaves enough space for queries, access to the page may be blocked immediately - in the meantime, persistent visitors are unsettled.
To summarize: Using security with responsibility
Activating HSTS is not cosmetic - it is a Real protective measure. Used correctly, it reduces serious risks in website operation. However, the step towards activation must be well prepared. If you take a structured approach, start with low max-age values and only use lock-in components such as preload after the test phase, you will benefit from reliable protection in the long term.
Especially in a time of constantly growing cyber threats, practical experience shows that sufficiently encrypted communication channels are essential. HSTS adds a crucial layer of security to the HTTPS protocol by preventing unencrypted connections from ever being allowed. Together with sophisticated certificate management and regular security checks, this creates an overall package that provides the best possible protection for your own data and users.
Security features such as HSTS are now part of the responsible operation of professional websites. I recommend that every admin familiarize themselves with the mechanism - and implement it in a targeted manner with a plan and monitoring. If you take the time to configure it properly, you will create a much more trustworthy environment and send a clear signal that the security of visitors and their data has top priority.
